At the October 7, Nova Festival thousands of young people were gathered in a quiet park near Gaza, many of them dancing to psytrance music with a giant illuminated Buddha in their midst. It was Shabbat and a day most observant Jews were celebrating Simchat Torah, a day dedicated as Joy of Torah. These festivities sound pretty condemnable, especially when you see the footage of the semi-nude dancers in their celebration of love and peace. But might there be another way to see it?

Perhaps we cross a red line when we open this topic—one that perhaps should be left in the virtual trash can and not resurrected.
So if this material is offensive, then you know what to do!

I certainly do not have all the answers! I could, in fact, be wrong and some of my best thoughts have been to ask others for their opinions. And I am going to do just that here. So please respond with your best judgment on this issue.

There are definite questions about the whole affair and most Bible believers would say that the dancers were doing something wrong or at least out of place. Were they?

And what part did the Eternal, Hashem, G-d, YHVH have to play in this? Was it discipline? Punishment? Was it that these dancers somehow opened up the door to the devil (evil, or however you call the dark side) by being in a state of idolatry? Immorality? Some would say so. Most of our world doesn’t even know the meaning of idolatry since it seems consigned to an era long past when people bowed down to images and believed they had some kind of magic powers.

Perhaps we should sweep this whole thing under the rug. But if we do, will there be a repeat of what happened? Has G-d somehow abandoned the Jewish people? Do we need to put some things under the microscope?

Why were foreign workers, who were in Israel simply to earn some money, slaughtered if it was about punishment for idolatry? They were not even present at the festival. I hate the word punishment and all it brings to mind although some declare it to be such. And how is the slaughter to be seen as punishment if nothing can be learned by it? At least not for those who died. But is there something for the rest of us to learn?

Why were there a lot of religious Jews slaughtered in their Kibbutzim if this was Hashem showing his anger? Could it have something to do with religion? Is there something that caused a rift among the young and blinded them to the 10 commandments? Keeping Shabbat? Immorality? Idolatry? How actually do the commandments play out in today’s world?

Can I play the devil’s advocate to extreme moralists? What if these people did not know the meaning of the commandments? What if somehow those who were Jewish were tired of all the burdens that were imposed upon them for the past myriad generations by those who taught religion to their ancestors? But if this be the case, then why were the foreign workers killed and some Muslims as well? Maybe it was not punishment. Or did this act open the door to something evil and as a result, a lot of innocent people got swept away with it?

Most of us who study the Bible know that dancing before a Buddha is wrong, actually similar to the Golden Calf at Sinai. But I think there is a difference. At Sinai, the act was done out of rebellion—just a few weeks after hearing G-d’s voice speak the commandments from the mountain. The Hebrews said something to Aaron about Moses having abandoned them and thought they needed a new leader. Some were ready to go back to Egypt. They were doing apparently what they had observed in Egypt and no, those who danced around the golden calf were not holy— that’s why Hashem told Moses to have them slaughtered. Wow! Seems so unjust in the light of modern thinking! And I say “seems” because maybe we have the wrong idea of G-d, again!

But what does this have to do with semi-nude dancing on Shabbat before a Buddha? Do we somehow need to go back to the Bible to learn what it says and means? Is somehow the Bible outdated?

If you have read this far, I am sure some of you are ready to stone me. It’s ok, then, let’s all throw out the Bible and be done with it! The problem may well be with a religion that has taken the place of the Bible. That the Bible—rather Torah, we hear, can only be understood by rabbis and we can only understand when we follow the interpretations written by the Sages. I remember Catholics telling me that only the priests in that religion can understand the Bible and so the members must go to mass to learn. Hmmm, has something similar happened in Judaism? Moses says in the Torah that it is not too hard to understand.

Deut. 30: 11“For this commandment that I command you today is not too hard for you, neither is it far off. 12 It is not in heaven, that you should say, ‘Who will ascend to heaven for us and bring it to us, that we may hear it and do it?’ 13 Neither is it beyond the sea, that you should say, ‘Who will go over the sea for us and bring it to us, that we may hear it and do it?’ 14 But the word is very near you. It is in your mouth and in your heart, so that you can do it.”

So why do we need extra interpretors? But that is beside the point in this article, it all boils down to why the apparently good suffered with those who were at least blinded to Torah and what was expected of them? I have heard it voiced on social media groups that we all need to become religiously observant in order that this not happen again. Then why were some of the people that were killed, raped or kidnapped, religious Jews? It doesn’t make sense.

So maybe we don’t have any clear answers, but we do need to take a closer look at the Judaism we know today how it compares to what was written in the Torah which came to us by the hand of Moses. Judaism claims to be the keeper of the Torah. But how close are its teaching to that which came down from Moses?

If our religion is wrong, we need to get it right. And yes, we are warned in the prophets that things like this would happen if we left the Torah. And on this theme, we might well ask, why the Holocaust? Why Pogroms? Are there answers? I hope so!

Ariella Golani

Follow Take Hold the Tzitzit on WordPress.com